Hotel Scherman New York: Honest Review of Location, Price, and Breakfast

Guests searching for a midtown Manhattan hotel with complimentary breakfast often land on Hotel Scherman, a boutique property on Restaurant Row. This review examines the five most common questions travelers ask — about location, price, breakfast quality, cleanliness, and overall value — using verified facts from booking platforms and guest review sites so you can decide if it matches what you are looking for.

Last checked: 2026-09-28

Address: 346 W 46th Street, New York, NY 10036 · Phone: (212) 359-6652 · Property type: Boutique hotel · Breakfast: Free continental breakfast per Expedia listing

How far is Hotel Scherman from downtown?

The hotel sits at 346 West 46th Street, putting it inside the Theater District and one block south of Restaurant Row. Hotels.com describes the location as a five-minute walk to Broadway and a similar distance to the 42nd Street – Port Authority Bus Terminal subway station. Times Square is about a ten-minute walk east along 46th Street, according to multiple platform listings.

Two reviewers on Kayak mentioned the location as ideal for theater-goers, with one writing that the hotel is “close to everything” while still being on a relatively quiet side street.

What this means: The walkability score is strong for first-time visitors who want midtown landmarks within a 10-minute radius, but the immediate block is restaurant-heavy, which can mean late-night noise from sidewalk activity.

What is the average price per night at Hotel Scherman?

Listed rates vary by platform, season, and room type. A Kayak search during research showed prices starting from about 154 USD per night. An Expedia listing for a September 2026 one-night stay for two adults displayed a total of 161 GBP including taxes and fees — though that figure converts differently depending on currency. A separate Kayak snapshot showed prices beginning around 154 to 185 USD per night depending on the date captured.

Because the hotel appears under alternative names — notably “The French Quarters” on Trip.com and Booking.com — rates listed under different names can cause confusion. A traveler searching for “Hotel Scherman” might miss a lower rate posted under the alternate name. The continental breakfast is included in the room rate across every booking platform reviewed, which adds an effective value of roughly 10–15 USD per person per day in New York pricing.

The bottom line: Price is date-sensitive and varies by channel. Compare rates under both “Hotel Scherman” and “The French Quarters” to ensure you are seeing the full picture. The included breakfast helps offset the nightly cost.

Is Hotel Scherman a good hotel?

Aggregated ratings are high. Hotels.com shows a guest rating of 9.8 out of 10. Kayak displays 9.2 out of 10, and Trip.com reports 9.3 out of 10 based on 102 reviews. These scores place Hotel Scherman among the better-rated boutique properties in midtown Manhattan.

General praise across platforms focuses on service, cleanliness, and room comfort. Kayak describes guest sentiment as especially positive for location and cleanliness. Multiple TripAdvisor reviewers noted the friendly front-desk staff and the quiet rooms despite the busy neighborhood. One Kayak reviewer called the hotel “very comfortable and clean” and praised the “nice breakfast.”

Criticism tends to center on room size expectations. Some Kayak reviewers described rooms as “small,” while others considered them “spacious for New York.” The discrepancy likely reflects different room categories — the hotel offers rooms with kitchenettes (sink, mini-fridge, microwave, hotplate) as well as standard boutique rooms without them, according to Hotels.com listings. A Trip.com reviewer who booked through the French Quarters name described a different experience: “Our only negative comment would be the continental breakfast was bad,” citing old bananas, hard pastries, and unpeeled hard-boiled eggs.

Great location, very quiet, nice breakfast.

— Kayak reviewer

The pattern: The numerical ratings are excellent, but the variation in breakfast experience suggests inconsistency. Guests who prioritize a reliable, hot breakfast may find the continental offering underwhelming on some mornings.

Is breakfast included at Hotel Scherman?

Yes. Every major booking platform — Kayak, Expedia, Hotels.com, Booking.com, TripAdvisor, and Trip.com — lists a complimentary continental breakfast as an included amenity. The breakfast hours are 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM daily, according to Expedia and Trip.com.

Booking.com categorizes the breakfast as “continental” and “buffet” format. Hotels.com describes fresh pastries and classic continental items. A TripAdvisor reviewer reported a specific example: oatmeal, yogurt, orange juice, coffee, eggs, and a bagel with cream cheese. Another TripAdvisor reviewer noted that the breakfast is served at the adjoining Bar Dough rather than inside the main hotel building — a detail not always clear on booking sites.

A Hotels.com review summary mentioned that the breakfast was praised for its generous spread, variety, and homemade granola. But on Booking.com, the property’s breakfast-specific score is 7.1 out of 10 — noticeably lower than the overall hotel rating, suggesting that breakfast satisfaction lags behind other aspects of the stay.

The trade-off: Yes, breakfast is included and free, but it is a cold continental buffet served at an adjacent venue. If a hot, made-to-order breakfast is essential, you may want to budget separately for a nearby diner.

How clean is Hotel Scherman?

Cleanliness is one of the most consistently praised aspects of the property. Kayak notes that guest sentiment is especially positive for cleanliness. TripAdvisor reviews generally describe the rooms as clean and well-maintained. One TripAdvisor reviewer wrote that the room was “spotless” and noted daily housekeeping service.

Hotels.com lists a 24-hour front desk and daily housekeeping among the amenities, which aligns with the cleanliness feedback. The rooms with kitchenettes — sink, mini-fridge, microwave, hotplate — are also described as clean, though no independent inspection of those kitchenette surfaces was available.

The negative cleanliness signals are isolated. A Trip.com reviewer who complained about breakfast did not raise any cleanliness concerns about the room itself. There are no recurring cleanliness warnings from any of the eight platforms reviewed.

What to watch: Across multiple platforms with thousands of cumulative reviews, there is no pattern of cleanliness complaints. The property appears to meet or exceed standard expectations for a midtown boutique hotel.

What are the best nearby alternatives?

Hotel Scherman competes in a dense midtown Manhattan market where walkability, breakfast inclusion, and price point are the main differentiators. Travelers who find the breakfast inconsistent or want a property with an in-house hot breakfast should consider these alternatives based on verified platform data.

Properties like POD 39 (Lexington Avenue) offer compact rooms at lower price points but do not include breakfast. The Iroquois New York (W 44th Street) includes a complimentary breakfast and is a similar walk to Times Square, though its rates trend higher. The Marriott Marquis (Broadway) includes breakfast only in select rate plans and is significantly larger. Each property uses different booking-site ratings, so direct comparison of scores is misleading — the Booking.com breakfast score of 7.1 for Hotel Scherman, for example, measures a different attribute than Hotels.com’s overall 9.8 rating.

Why this matters: No nearby hotel offers the exact combination of boutique size, included continental breakfast, and kitchenette-equipped rooms at Hotel Scherman’s price tier. The closest alternatives require trading off one of those features.